Sr. Mary Sheila Alumni Scholarship
| Year | Winners |
| 2016 | Meghan Delaney |
| 2016 | Jamie Lynn Sessler |
| 2015 | Carol Christiansen |
| 2015 | Jennifer Medina |
| 2014 | James Wilson |
| 2014 | Margaret McCarthy |
| 2013 | Michelle Johnson |
| 2013 | Trisha Palmer |
| 2012 | Laura Patrick |
| 2012 | Valerie Granger |
| 2011 | Elizabeth O’Neil |
| 2011 | Ruth Hladky |
| 2010 | Heather Brown |
| 2010 | Serda Bazile |
| 2009 | Holly Hand |
| 2009 | Brittany Thomas |
| 2009 | Brandy Champagne |
| 2008 | Stephanie Kalemba |
| 2008 | Katelin Kingsley |
| 2007 | Jessica Blankenbush |
| 2007 | Maureen Murphy |
| 2006 | Paul Goodwin |
| 2006 | Sara Pelkey |
| 2005 | Michelle Maselli |
| 2004 | Elissa Craig |
| 2004 | Crystal Goering |
| 2003 | Lyndi Elizabeth Coon |
| 2003 | Mary Elizabeth Salmon |
| 2002 | Jennifer Lawler |
| 2002 | Sandra Denniston |
| 2001 | Kathleen Proulx |
| 2001 | Kelly Anne Seifried |
| 2000 | Sarah McIntyre |
| 2000 | Leslie White |
| 1999 | Lisa Martin |
| 1999 | Kristin McCormick |
| 1998 | Lynn Proulx |
| 1998 | Jennifer Henderson |
| 1997 | Lisa Hass |
| 1997 | Bethany Osborne |
| 1996 | Bryan Day |
| 1996 | Roberta Percy |
| 1995 | Daniel Munding |
| 1995 | Jeanette Rainbow |
